Italian Restaurants in Midtown

Italian restaurants in Midtown, ranked by diners' ratings and our editors' picks, with hours, today's specials and happy hours. How we rank

15 restaurants

Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria

Italian·$$
4.7 (340 on Google)
ClosedMidtown4910 Tamiami Trl N #124, Naples

Family-run Italian house and pizzeria serving pasta, pies and classic mains.

Today2 Plain Slices & A Soda · $10.30
Visit websiteCallView profile

Trattoria Mangia

Italian·$$
4.6 (370 on Google)
ClosedMidtown4025 Santa Barbara Blvd, Naples

Classic trattoria serving housemade pasta and traditional Italian fare.

Visit websiteCallView profile
MiraMare Ristorante 1MiraMare Ristorante 2MiraMare Ristorante 3MiraMare Ristorante 4

MiraMare Ristorante

Italian, Pizza·$$$
4.1 (730 on Google)
ClosedMidtown4236 Gulf Shore Blvd N, Naples

MiraMare Ristorante, located in the elegant Venetian Village, offers an upscale waterfront dining experience with a focus on authentic Italian cuisine. Specialties include fresh seafood, handmade pastas, and wood-fired pizzas, all enjoyed with beautiful views of Venetian Bay.

Date NightOutdoor DiningRomanticWaterfront
Happy hourToday 3pm–6pm · $8 House Wine
ReserveCallView profile
Bellini Italian Restaurant And Bar 1

Bellini Italian Restaurant And Bar

Italian·$$
4.4 (493 on Google)
ClosedMidtown2331 Tamiami Trl N, Naples

Casual cafe with outdoor seating serving reimagined Italian dishes.

Today3 Course Menu · $59 + tax & 20% gratuity
Visit websiteCallView profile

Aldos Italian Table & Bar

Italian·$$
4.4 (547 on Google)
ClosedMidtown5306, 4820 Davis Blvd, Naples

Comfy Italian bistro serving NY-style pizza, wine and classic Italian staples.

Visit websiteCallView profile

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Italian·$$
4.5 (2,069 on Google)
ClosedMidtown4320 Tamiami Trl N, Naples

Chain eatery and bar serving a diverse menu of classic Italian fare.

Group FriendlyCasual Catch UpKid Friendly
Happy hourToday 4pm–7pm · $3 Michelob Ultra
Visit websiteCallView profile
California Pizza Kitchen 1California Pizza Kitchen 2

California Pizza Kitchen

Italian, Pizza·$$
4.3 (585 on Google)
ClosedMidtown5555 Tamiami Trail N, Naples

California Pizza Kitchen (CPK), located at the Waterside Shops, offers a casual and family-friendly dining experience, known for its innovative, California-style pizzas like BBQ Chicken Pizza and Thai Chicken Pizza. In addition to pizza, the menu features a variety of pastas, salads, and sandwiches, catering to diverse tastes.

Visit websiteCallView profile
Rosati's Pizza 1

Rosati's Pizza

Italian, Pizza·$$
4.3 (518 on Google)
ClosedMidtown818 Neapolitan Way, Naples

Italian chain featuring Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, pasta and sandwiches.

Casual Catch UpKid Friendly
Visit websiteCallView profile

Amore Ristorante

Italian·$$$
4.2 (311 on Google)
ClosedMidtown4681 Tamiami Trl N, Naples

Elevated Italian fare and a large array of wines in a warm traditional space.

Date NightRomantic
Visit websiteCallView profile

IL Primo Pizza & Wings

Italian·$$
4.4 (894 on Google)
ClosedMidtown5248 Golden Gate Pkwy, Naples

Local chain serving chicken wings and made-to-order pizzas in a relaxed setting.

Visit websiteCallView profile

Tony’s N.Y. Pizza

Italian·$
4.3 (305 on Google)
ClosedMidtown7335 Radio Rd #107, Naples

Neighborhood slice shop serving New York-style pizza and Italian staples.

Visit websiteCallView profile

Napoli On The Bay V

Italian·$$
3.7 (230 on Google)
ClosedMidtown13020 Livingston Rd APT 6, Naples

Italian pizzeria and deli offering pies, subs and gelato in a casual setting.

Visit websiteCallView profile

Aurelio's Pizza of Naples

Italian, Pizza·$$
Midtown6270 Naples Blvd #6, Naples

Longtime chain known for pizzas, pastas and Italian staples in a casual setting.

Casual Catch UpKid Friendly
Visit websiteCallView profile

Peppi's Pizzeria

Pizza, Italian·$
Midtown4111 Tamiami Trail N, Naples

Peppi's Pizzeria, located at 4111 Tamiami Trail North in Naples, Florida, is a well-loved Italian restaurant known for its delicious pizza and a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. This pizzeria offers a range of Italian cuisine, including perfectly cooked pepperoni pizzas, various pies, and spaghetti. They also serve tasty cannolis and provide a selection of drinks, including wine, beer, and margaritas.

Jet's Pizza

Italian·$
4.0 (464 on Google)
ClosedMidtown4009 Santa Barbara Blvd, Naples

Counter-serve chain offering Detroit-style pizza, wings and subs.

Visit websiteCallView profile

Browse Naples restaurants

Lists from Visit Naples

Hand-picked guides by the editors at Visit Naples, our sister site.

How we rank restaurants

Our editors rank the list. They weigh what diners say (each restaurant's Google rating, counted for more the more people have reviewed it) with what a rating can't show: whether it's a destination worth the trip, its setting, our Editors' Picks and the guides in which the editors at Visit Naples recommend it.

Featured restaurants are partners of the Visit Naples network, shown in turn in the Featured row and labelled wherever they appear. Partnership never buys a place in the ranked list; it only breaks a near-tie.